Legal Blog
Commercial and Companies
Commercial and Companies
Must the creditor of an SCI sue the company before the partners have sold their shares in order to be able to sue the partners for repayment?
Cass. civ. 3rd, 6 June 2024, no. 23-10.526 Must the creditor of an SCI sue the company before the partners have sold their shares in order to be able to sue the partners for repayment? This was the question addressed by the Third Civil Chamber of the Court of...
The asset freeze: a retaliatory measure against dictators
Retaliation and Challenges Asset freezing is a common retaliatory measure used against dictators, as evidenced by the cases of Muammar Gaddafi, Zine El Abidine Ben Ali and Hosni Mubarak during the “Arab Spring”. This two-minute guide aims to shed light on how this...
Recognition of the moral prejudice of a company
Implications and Clarifications for the first time, the Court of Cassation explicitly recognizes that a company – but the solution certainly applies to all legal persons – can invoke moral damage. Court of Cassation's Recognition of Moral Damage for Legal Persons:-...
SFR attacks Orange on its offers for second homes
The operator SFR brought an action before the Commercial Court of Paris against Orange concerning the offers made to owners of secondary residences. It will be recalled that France Telecom markets a fixed telephony offer and an Internet offer at 19 and 21 euros...
The Tax Credit for Competitiveness and Employment (CICE)
Since the beginning of 2013, companies have been able to benefit from the CICE , which corresponds to a tax credit equal to 4% of the amount of remuneration lower than 2.5 times the minimum wage. The refund is immediate and no longer chargeable to income tax. The CICE...
Covid-19: economic challenges and solutions
Economic Challenges and Solutions The ongoing Covid-19 outbreak in France has presented an unprecedented health crisis, leading to significant economic challenges for businesses across the country. Economic challenges and solutions amid the Covid-19 outbreak:-...
Tax Evasion vs Tax Avoidance
Tax Evasion vs Tax Avoidance The distinction between tax evasion and tax avoidance can often blur, but it's a line that the so-called 'ghost' company in Luxembourg has shrewdly grasped. There is a fine line between tax evasion and tax avoidance. The Luxembourg...
COVID impact on restaurant owners
In five decisions, rendered on September 17, 2020 , the Paris Commercial Court ordered the insurance company AXA to compensate several restaurateurs for their operating losses resulting from their administrative closure. AXA's refusal to compensate restaurant...
Covid-19 and insolvency proceedings
Financial Challenges Crisis The ongoing health crisis has forced the government to take immediate action to alleviate the challenges facing businesses, including by offering simplified conditions for insolvency proceedings. Insolvency proceedings under simplified...
The obligation to file annual accounts
Ensuring compliance with the obligation to file annual accounts: legal consequences and enforcement measures According to article L 123-12 of the Commercial Code, it is compulsory for all traders to draw up annual accounts at the end of the financial year. With...
Clarification of tax exemption
Clarifying tax exemption Exemption of financial investments: impact and relief for non-residents In a significant judgment, the Court of Cassation clarified that the financial investments of non-residents are exempt from the wealth solidarity tax (ISF), without...
Thomas Cook bankruptcy: consequences and support for affected travelers
Thomas Cook bankruptcy The collapse of Thomas Cook: implications and support for affected travelers On Monday, September 23, 2019, the famous travel giant, Thomas Cook , declared bankruptcy, bringing its business operations to a complete halt. Unable to raise the...
Glyphosate Controversies
For several years controversies have arisen as to the effects of the use of weedkillers, in particular Roundup, well known to farmers and even Sunday gardeners. The increasing number of lawsuits aim to demonstrate the dangerousness of the glyphosate contained in large...
The consequences of the Macron Law for the legal professions
The Law for Growth, Activity and Equal Economic Opportunity, known as the Macron Law , includes a section concerning the legal professions . Interprofessional Practice Firms: Improving Collaboration Between Legal Professions: – Law n° 2015-990 of August 6, 2015 was...
SAS and drafting of statutes
The legislator left great freedom to the drafters of the articles of association to define which decisions must be taken by the shareholders' association and which decisions can be taken by any other body of the SAS . Flexibility in SAS governance Article L. 227-9 of...
Law of companies in difficulty: the novelties of the law of March 12, 2014
Located at the heart of current economic and social issues, and propelled to the rank of central discipline of business law by the economic and financial crisis that has shaken the country for more than five years now, the law of companies in difficulty is, almost as...
The works council through which a trip was organized is not a travel agency!
The works council as an intermediary The works council through which a trip has been organized with a tour operator is not itself a travel agency. Consequently, he is not subject to the same obligations as the latter. This was ruled by the Court of Cassation in a...
Electronic payment obligations for corporation tax and payroll tax
Digital tax complianceSince October 1, 2011, companies have been required to pay their corporation tax electronically if their turnover exceeds 230,000 euros excluding tax. In addition, companies subject to corporation tax are required to telepay their tax debts ....
Valuation of shares in a Professional Civil Society
Share valuation dynamics This new decision relating to the valuation of the shares of a partner in a professional non-trading company hardly deserves comment . Evaluation of Actions in a Professional Civil Society : The Force of the Texts:- A recent decision...
Right to deduct: cost of sale of equity securities
The Council of State has laid down the rules applicable to the deductibility of VAT paid on expenses related to the sale of equity securities. When a holding company, which engages in an economic activity for which it is subject to VAT, plans to sell all or part of...
Beware of false manager status!
Your content goes here. Edit or remove this text inline or in the module Content settings. You can also style every aspect of this content in the module Design settings and even apply custom CSS to this text in the module Advanced settings. Recently, several cases of...
Simplification of the trade and companies register
Simplification measures for the trade and companies register :- Simplification of the register The decree of July 31, 2012 introduced several simplification measures concerning the formalities completed in the trade and companies register and its keeping. These...
Partnership: the presumption of distribution of income does not apply where amounts are made available to a partnership rather than directly to the individual partner
Presumption of income The presumption that the sums paid by a company to its partner as advances constitute income distributed to the partner unless proven otherwise (CGI, art. 111, a) does not apply when the sums are made available to a partnership of which the...
Representation of companies: publication of the appointment of the manager to the RCS
The Court of Cassation recalls that from the date of his appointment, the new manager is authorized to represent the legal person in all acts of the criminal proceedings followed against him, regardless of whether this appointment has not yet been published in the...
Law of companies in difficulty: details on the powers of the liquidator
Jurisdiction of the liquidator: jurisdiction and limits The case revolves around a situation where a Société Civile Immobilière (SCI) sells one of its buildings, but the buyer delays registering the price. In addition , the manager of the SCI is placed in judicial...
Unpaid bills and late payment interest: freedom of contract must take precedence!
To anticipate unpaid bills, it is always advisable to include a clause relating to late payment interest to make them run as soon as possible. As part of a share transfer operation, the transferor has sued the transferee in order to obtain the balance of the...
Partial contribution of assets: absence of the autonomous nature of the activities contributed
When the contributed activity is dependent on other ancillary activities, it does not constitute an independent branch of activity, likely to benefit from the partial asset contribution regime. A Company contributed to another company, on the one hand, its activity of...
Selling computers with pre-installed software is not always an unfair business practice
The Court of Cassation refuses to consider, with regard to the sale of computers online, that the sale of a computer with pre-installed software constitutes an unfair commercial practice , since the customer has the possibility of acquiring on a website linked this...
Taxation of GFA Shares
The taxation of GFA (Groupements Fonciers Agricoles) shares under the Impôt sur la Fortune Immobilière (IFI) is typically based on their market value as of January 1st of the tax year. However, exemptions exist when the shares qualify as professional property or are...
Company law: non-compliance with the stipulations contained in the articles of association of a company does not automatically result in the nullity of the act
Nullity of acts amending the statutes of commercial companies Under the terms of Article L. 235-1 of the Commercial Code , the nullity of an act modifying the statutes of a commercial company can only be found if there is an express provision of the Commercial Code...
Registration of the lessee in the RCS and suspension of the biennial prescription; (Civ. 3rd, July 4, 2012, FS-P+B, no. 11-13.868).
This judgment of rejection will attract attention, on the one hand, in that it relates to the regularity of the lessee's registration in the RCS required by Article L. 145-1 of the Commercial Code and, on the other hand, on the other hand, because he is interested in...
Effect of the request for suspension of the effects of the termination clause included in a commercial lease
Request for delay and suspension: termination of the commercial lease According to Article L. 145-41 of the Commercial Code , the holder of a commercial lease has the right to request delays and the suspension of the effects of the resolutory clause, even after...
Business transfer: the Dutreuil pact
The Dutreil Pact is a measure aimed at promoting the transfer of businesses by offering significant tax benefits to both companies and sole proprietorships . In this article, we will explore key aspects of Dutreil schemes, including eligibility criteria and...
Company law: legal independence of group companies
In a corporate group , the entities that make up the group are legal persons that retain their legal independence from each other. Furthermore, it is important to note that the group as a whole does not have legal personality. Accordingly, the principle of the...
Respect for Sunday rest: admissibility of a company’s interim action: decision of the Court of Cassation of May 30, 2012
When employees work illegally on Sundays and two companies carry out a similar activity near a third, the latter has a legitimate interest in putting an end to this situation.Indeed, the breach of equality between them creates a prejudice.However, in terms of trade,...
Self-employed: what are the pitfalls to avoid?
Auto-entrepreneur : the status is attractive… but presents certain risks that it is better to know before starting. What are the pitfalls to avoid and the possible remedies ? Operating costs : Operating expenses are not deducted on the basis of the costs actually...
Can a company pollute with impunity?
Disasters caused by man are on the increase… and under the pressure of public opinion, the law and justice increasingly and severely penalize companies that pollute . WATER : The Erika trial made it possible for the first time to see individuals, local authorities and...
Accident Classification
Work Accident: A work accident is an incident that occurs during the course of work, characterized by a sudden and violent event taking place at the time and location of work. 1.1. Bodily Injury: One essential condition to classify an accident as a work accident is...
Acknowledgment of debt: how to ensure its validity?
It is sometimes difficult to establish an acknowledgment of debt , especially if the debtor is a relative or a member of his family… However, it is an act which can greatly facilitate the recovery of the sums lent. What are the mandatory information and the...
Over-indebtedness: how to challenge the commission’s opinion?
If the decision made by the over-indebtedness commission does not satisfy you, it is possible to contest it. What can be disputed? Each stage of the over-indebtedness procedure may be the subject of a dispute: it may be the inadmissibility of the request, in...
IOU: can it be cancelled?
Sometimes you want to cancel an IOU . The acknowledgment of debts being a legal act, is it possible ? How to try to obtain its cancellation? Yes, if there is a defect of consent The acknowledgment of debts being a legal act, the consent of the debtor must be free...
Judicial liquidation: explanations and operation
Debt release! It is during the judicial liquidation procedure that the question of the future of professional debts arises. A liquidator will then take care of the administration of the goods and their sale to settle the debts and reimburse the creditors. Even if...
Why create an SCI?
The civil real estate company allows the holding of one or more real estate by different people. In which cases is it interesting to create an SCI, and what are the advantages? What is an SCI used for? A civil real estate company (SCI) has as its object the...
The lawyer’s deed to secure the commercial lease
The drafting of the commercial lease is an important moment for both the lessee and the lessor. Thanks to the lawyer's act, the two parties secure very specific points which could prove to be contentious, such as the inventory or the termination of the lease. ...
External growth operations: good to know
External growth operations are complex and sometimes risky processes. Here are the points to keep in mind before you start. What is the nature of the operation? There are several types of external growth, acquisition or disposal operation . At least three questions...
Creating business on the internet
To start a commercial activity on the internet, there are precautions to take. Once the form of activity has been chosen, it is necessary to check the availability of the sign and to guard against possible disputes with buyers. Choose the right legal status: If the...
Are there any aids for setting up a business when you are unemployed?
There are various aid schemes for an unemployed person who wishes to set up his own business: exemption from social charges, support scheme, aid from Pôle Emploi or partial maintenance of allowances… To be able to benefit from it, certain conditions must be met:...
The EIRL, to create a company without risking its own assets
Creating a company is a process that can be cumbersome and complex. To commit only part of your assets, the EIRL is a good solution. Since January 2011, there is a new status for the company: the sole proprietorship with limited liability (EIRL). Previously,...
Can I set up my business at home?
Depending on the type of activity, one may want to set up his business from home. Is it legal? Do you have to meet certain conditions? Can this be advantageous? Yes, temporarily It is possible for an individual entrepreneur or a company manager to install the...
What to know before joining
You want to start a business but lack expertise, experience, capital? A partner may be the solution. Provided you take the usual precautions: Reasons for taking on a partner: It is important to join forces when looking for additional skills (management,...
Shareholders’ agreement: what you need to know
In a public limited company, the shareholders establish a shareholders' pact which organizes the life of the company and its management. A certain number of clauses make it possible to optimize coordination between the shareholders, in particular concerning the...
What if my customer does not pay his invoice?
Unpaid invoices have long been the main source of financial difficulty for businesses. However, there are many legal tools to defend yourself. Request payment of the invoice: If a customer fails to pay one or more invoices within the agreed period, the...
Should a late invoice be honoured?
Sometimes an invoice is sent long after the service. Is the customer then obliged to pay? Can the company claim its settlement indefinitely? Yes, unless there is a prescription The service provider cannot demand payment of his invoice from his client...
Avoid bankruptcy filing: safeguard measures
To avoid filing for bankruptcy, the company must quickly put in place safeguard measures . What are they ? Can the entrepreneur first enter into an amicable agreement with his creditors? Beforehand: As soon as the company notices a fall in its cash flow,...
Transfer of shares, instructions for use
The transfer of shares requires a certain number of guarantees, both for the purchaser and for the transferor. The lawyer's deed allows both parties to protect themselves against any disputes that may arise after the assignment. The importance of the spouse: The...
Notification operations, how to use
The acquisition of a stake in a company or the creation of a joint subsidiary with other partners are operations that must be notified to the competition authorities. The company must be particularly vigilant because it exposes itself to heavy penalties....
The obligation of loyalty and information in the sale of shares
The transferee is not required to inform the transferor either of negotiations aimed at the acquisition by a third party of other securities of the same company or of those which he conducts himself with this third party with a view to transferring or bringing to him...
Repression of misuse of corporate assets
The misuse of corporate assets is an offense under the legislation on commercial companies. Consequently, the reference text is not the Criminal Code but the Commercial Code which, in an entire title devoted to criminal provisions, is equivalent to a real Criminal...
Manager’s duty of loyalty to partners
The transferee is not required to inform the transferor either of negotiations aimed at the acquisition by a third party of other securities of the same company or of those which he conducts himself with this third party with a view to transferring or providing him...
Corporate negotiation: a decentralization of the production of legal norms
The existence of private economic powers is indisputable. Private governance is based on the existence of private economic powers. The power of certain companies, linked to the phenomena of concentration, makes them more powerful than certain States. This power is a...
European business associations: a decisive development for the 21st century
Community co-legislators struggled for more than thirty years to harmonize company law within the European Union. Their ambitions were scaled back after the failure of each negotiation. This was the case for the European company but also for the European cooperative...
Suretyship and universal transfer of assets
As in the case of the death of a natural person, the merger of two legal persons entails, with the disappearance of the company, a universal transfer of assets to the benefit of the absorbing company or the new company resulting from the merger. However, the Court of...
The necessary transformation of the association, economic and social agent in 2022
The evolution of the law reveals a tendency towards the diversification of structures. Certain forms of legal persons, such as associations, are increasingly being used as an alternative to corporations for the exercise of economic activities in the competitive...
The necessary evolution of company law
THE QUESTION Company law may be giving way to company law. Indeed, recent legislative developments lead to a clearer and clearer distinction between partner, shareholder and investor, as well as between listed and unlisted companies. This economic reality has been...
The fate of suretyship in merger operations: developments and clarifications in case law
On November 8, 2005, the commercial chamber of the Court of Cassation made a major reversal of case law by enshrining the automatic transfer of the suretyship in the event of merger-absorption of the beneficiary company.This decision, awaited for many years by...
The questioning of the notion of partner
Company law is giving way to company law. Indeed, recent legislative developments lead to a clearer and clearer distinction between partner and investor, as well as between listed companies and unlisted companies. For example, the decree of December 11, 2006 ,...
European companies
Community co-legislators have struggled for more than thirty years to harmonize company law within the European Union. Their ambitions were scaled back after each failed negotiation .This was the case for the European company but also for the European cooperative...
Takeovers of companies carrying out a banking activity in 2022
Difficulties raised by takeovers of companies carrying out a banking activity in 2022. Company law, when defining the notion of control , provides a number of thresholds. Banking law, in article 2 of Regulation n° 96-16 of 20/12/1996, refers to the acquisition...
business negotiation
The article demonstrates that company negotiation is the way to operate a decentralized legal regulation at company level. In many restructurings, companies find solutions through social agreements on employment. The latter highlight a decentralization of the...